Thursday, July 03, 2008

The Death Penalty as Punishment for the Rape of Children

Melissa's post reminded me of a topic that I've been meaning to post about. Until about a week ago, the rape of a child in Louisiana was a offense punishable by the death penalty. Last Wednesday, the Supreme Court

struck down a Louisiana law that allows capital punishment for people convicted of raping children under 12. It spares the only people in the U.S. under sentence of death for that crime — two Louisiana men convicted of raping girls 5 and 8.

The ruling also invalidates laws on the books in five other states that allowed executions for child rape that does not result in the death of the victim.

The Supreme Court offered the ruling "despite the 'years of long anguish' for victims." And while I don't dispute the reasoning or evidence behind that phrase, I do find it and similar sentiments problematic.

Since the case originated in Louisiana, it was big news here. The local paper that I read most often carried the news on the front page. It quoted District Attorney Jerry Jones as saying,
The rape of a child is the most heinous crime I can think of. In first-degree murder, it's over. The victim does not continue to suffer. The victims of child rape are destined to a life of misery and suffering.
And immediately, I was piqued by that.

Rape, no matter who the victim is, is a heinous crime. The most terrifying feeling that I have ever had in my life, EVER, is being held down and unable to stop or control what was happening to my own body. I cannot even adequately describe that feeling. And I would be lying if I said I didn't have particular contempt for people who rape children.

But I think the notion that victims of child rape are "destined" to be miserable relies not solely on the survivors' own experiences, but our own biases. Like our obsessions with "purity" and "innocence." Like the idea that rape somehow stigmatizes the victim. Like the belief that virginity is a "gift" to be bestowed upon someone, the mark of a "moral" woman.

I am not at all saying that being the victim of a rape doesn't cause anguish, misery and suffering. I am agreeing with what Melissa said in comments, that
rape is something with which a survivor has to live for the rest of her or his life, which is a true thing, but a lot of people are incapable of saying that without implying the rape is a stain on the soul or the survivor is somehow irreparably broken, damaged goods.

Because it's something we carry doesn't necessarily mean it's a burden; that it has changed us shouldn't mean it marks us differently than the other things that change a person in a lifetime.
(Emphasis mine)


3 comments:

elle said...

Kimberly said...

I agree with you 100%. All rape is horrendous. It can scar a person deeply. But the "destiny" described here underestimates the resiliency of the human spirit and absolutely stigmatizes the victim and the worth of their existence.

For me, I am against the death penalty in child rape cases for a couple of reasons. As with capital murder, I have no illusions that minorities wouldn't be over-represented among those convicted and sentenced to death for child rape. But even more importantly, what keeps the rapist from killing the victim if they can suffer the same consequence for murder and rape? I realize some may think that child's life is going to be worthless...what with them being "destined to a life of misery and suffering"...but I tend to hope they get the chance to live and prove those people wrong.
July 03, 2008 10:58 PM

elle said...

Kismet said...

I am really glad you posted on this. I share some of the same concerns with capital punishment as Kimberly. But I am also becoming aware of my own assumptions about survivors of sexual assault, adult and child. It is helpful to have that put in an analysis that also thinks about assumptions and hierarchies that relate to gender and to sexuality. And then to relate all of that back to the prison industrial complex....

yes indeedee. simple and yet complex work here elle in, what? 500 words? Rock on sistorian-soror! Rock on!
July 04, 2008 12:48 AM

Melissa McEwan said...

I think the notion that victims of child rape are "destined" to be miserable relies not solely on the survivors' own experiences, but our own biases. Like our obsessions with "purity" and "innocence." Like the idea that rape somehow stigmatizes the victim. Like the belief that virginity is a "gift" to be bestowed upon someone, the mark of a "moral" woman.

Spot on. And don't you think a lot of that is due to projection by people who can't imagine that they'd ever recover if it happened to them? They can't imagine how anyone could go on...

And that, of course, is intimately related to the stereotypes we hold about how rape victims are "supposed" to act. How many rape cases have been lost because the defense was able to convince the jury the victim didn't "act" like one?

"She didn't have complete meltdown! Why, she got up every morning and went to work and cooked her dinner and did her laundry as if nothing had happened! She didn't act like a broken piece of human waste at all!"

Grumble grumble grumble and grr.

Revelations and ruminations from one southern sistorian...